The alternative formulated in the title has a chance to be settled, when the existence of the LSND effect is experimentally excluded or confirmed. The first option, much discussed in literature, works in the case of three active neutrinos \nu e \nu \mu \nu \tau , when among their massive states \nu 1 \nu 2 \nu 3 there is no direct mixing between \nu 1 and \nu 3 , and the mass hierarchy m21 \lesssim m22 \ll m23 holds. This option is consistent with the observed deficits of solar \nu e's and atmospheric \nu \mu 's, if \Delta m221 \leftrightarrow \Delta m2sol and \Delta m232 \leftrightarrow \Delta m2atm . On the other hand, the second option is an extension of the idea of the former to the case of four neutrinos \nu s , \nu e , \nu \mu , \nu \tau (including one sterile neutrino \nu s ), when among their massive states \nu 0 , \nu 1 , \nu 2 , \nu 3 there are no direct mixings between \nu 0 and \nu 2 , \nu 0 and \nu 3 , \nu 1 and \nu 3 , and the mass hierarchy m20\lesssim m21 \ll m22 \lesssim m23 is now valid. Such an option, belonging to a class of textures widely discussed in literature, may be consistent with the observed deficits of solar \nu e 's and atmospheric \nu \mu 's as well as with the LSND appearance of \nu e 's in the beam of accelerator \nu \mu 's, if now \Delta m210 \leftrightarrow \Delta m2sol , \Delta m232 \leftrightarrow \Delta m2atm and \Delta m221 \leftrightarrow \Delta m2LSND (however, in the case of solar \nu e 's the role of \nu s 's in the disappearance of \nu e 's is recently questioned). In both options, only the close neighbours in the hierarchies of massive neutrinos \nu 1 , \nu 2 , \nu 3 and \nu 0, \nu 1, \nu , \nu 3, respectively, mix directly}. This characteristic feature of the two-mixing texture for three neutrinos or the three-mixing texture for four neutrinos may be somehow physically significant.
PACS numbers: 12.15.Ff, 14.60.Pq, 12.15.Hh
| Table of Contents | Back to Number 1 contents |